Thursday, July 17, 2014

Final Reflection: What are the aims of diversity?



As I sit here reflecting the question What are the aims of diversity? I must acknowledge that it expands beyond the scope of my perspective and it will continue to evolve throughout my life experiences. Only now can I begin to unpack the concept of diversity with the introduction that I have been given and with a new perspective that I have began to form. This is just the beginning of a new consciousness.

I am an artist familiar with the terms frame and perspective because I use both to narrow a viewer’s focus on an intended subject shown in a particular manner within a painting. The same idea holds true in the media as described by Kendall, “media frames constitute a mental short (schema) that helps us formulate our thoughts” (p. 449). I have used this knowledge to apply to my new understanding of diversity and the categories that used to frame the way I viewed the world. As I look beyond the frame that society has created, I begin to discover that diversity is essentially linked to an identity that requires a continuum of variations not a set of traits that fit within a single frame.

Identities are comprised of traits that are defined and constructed by society. As discussed by Seidman, “identities refer to the way we think of ourselves and the self image we publicly project” (p. 269). Identities are constructed by our own view of ourselves as well as the way we are perceived by others. According to Seidman, “we fashion identities by drawing on a culture that already associates identities with certain behaviors, places, and things” (p. 269), associations created by previous assumptions and categories that fail to acknowledge the complexities of human nature. Take for instance sex, the categorization of an individual into one of two distinct categories, man or woman. In Reading 10, Dreger discusses the investigation determining the sex of the world-champion runner, Caster Semenya, and the difficulties that ensued because of the complexities in determining sex. The level of complexity remains present in sexual orientation, gender, and race, to name just a few categories that are not as cut and dry as they first appear. As we acknowledge the presence of difference, we must also recognize the importance of moving beyond a color-blind approach of ignoring differences. A color-blind approach fails to recognize that individuals incorporate traits that make them unique as well as the ranking system of each trait on a hierarchical scale determined by society that justifies and propels inequitable treatment. 

The inequitable treatment of individuals resides in a hierarchical scale created, defined, and upheld by society. As discussed by Rosenblum and Travis (2012), “ideologies confer meaning on difference; they both shape and are shaped by social institutions” (p. 348). As ideologies and social institutions co-construct the meaning of difference, categories isolate specific traits and certain individuals. In Reading 30 Lareau and Weininger explore the impact of different forms of child rearing in middle-class families, working-class families, and poor families with concerns to middle school, high school, and college. The authors suggest that the higher education application process supports middle-class families and  “this knowledge, and the associated dispositions, may be viewed as a form of “cultural capitol”—one that is clearly implicated in the long-term persistence of inequality” (p. 301). Similar to the structure of the education systems, the healthcare systems illustrates that “inequity kills and it starts at the bottom” (Reuss, p. 304). Difference does affect the lives of individuals when social programs uphold inequitable treatment through systems used to categorize and propel classifications and discriminate against those that embody traits labeled as inferior.

The aims of diversity are to recognize the complexities of identities, celebrating our individual and unique traits by continually developing new perspectives to view our own identity and the identities of others. A new perspective requires listening, validating the personal experiences of others as much as we validate our own experiences. The invisible becomes visible to an active listener and provides the opportunity to see things differently that move beyond superficial assumptions. A raised awareness assists the ability to critically assess the groupings we use to selectively categorize specific traits and question why they were developed and how they are currently defined to cultivate an understanding that extends beyond what we have been told and are accustomed to hearing. If we have constructed these categories we can mindfully reject them to appreciate the complexity of human life.

As we recognize that we define and construct differences we can become empowered to change the way that we view differences. We can begin by recognizing and remaining conscious of our own actions, modeling and supporting equitable treatment that provides an entry point for others. The question remains, will we make people conform and fit into pre-determined categories or create environments and systems that adapt and address the complexities exhibited by the individual?

I will continue to learn about the complexities of each individual’s identity every day and plan to adapt the environment around me to address and support the needs of the individual. Although I plan to teach art, ideas about diversity can become intertwined within each lesson and each interaction I have in the classroom. I hope to inspire discussions that address differences, encouraging and celebrating dialogue rather than hiding or erasing unfamiliar and uncomfortable topics. As we expose ideas about diversity to students, we may spark ideas and actions that continue beyond the classroom. According to Seidman,“respecting and valuing group differences is a key part of this nation’s identity” (p. 273). As an educator I strive to provide opportunities for students to develop and display a personal identity that incorporates both an individual consciousness and a collective consciousness.

I move forward with a new understanding and appreciation for difference, individual experiences and stories, and an awareness that breaks away from the socially constructed frame. Frames belong around works of art, not personal perspectives from which to view the world. A raised consciousness extends beyond the confines of a frame and continues to grow if encouraged.

References

Rosenblum, K. E., & Travis, T. C. 2012. The meaning of difference: American constructions of race, sex and gender, social class, sexual orientation, and disability. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Reading 10, Dreger, A. Where’s the Rulebook for Sex Verification?
Reading 27, Seidman, S. Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life
Reading 30, Lareau, A., & Weininger, E. B. Class and the Transition to Adulthood
Reading 31, Reuss, A. Cause of Death: Inequality
Reading 45, Kendall, D. Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America

Digital Journal 7/15


Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Blog Post 14: Making the invisible visible

The experiences of every individual remain essential and valid, even when the experiences seem very different than others interprets them to be. In Reading 34, French describes her experiences as an individual with partial sight and the difficulties she endured throughout her life as her own personal experiences failed to be recognized by her parents, teachers, friends, or bystanders. As French stated, “the nature of my disability was defined by other people” (p. 322). French often denied her disability in order to please others. French discussed her childhood experiences comprised of adults wanting her to increase her ability to see with new technological advances that failed to have any impact. French’s own experience were often overlooked by the adults that surrounded her with the overbearing intentions of wanting her to see, never asking for her opinion as a child with partial sight. As an adult, French describes the difficulties of living with a disability that remained invisible to a bystander or co-worker unless a discussion later ensued. Even a discussion conveyed a sense of identity as described by her disability. French’s experiences emphasize the importance of listening to personal experiences rather than relying on assumptions. Experiences provide first-hand accounts that allow outsiders an inside look if they recognize the opportunity. While many disabilities remain invisible to the eye, they can become visible by listening to individuals like French share their experiences and opinions.

While reading the article I began to think about how the experiences of children are often overlooked. When troubling events happen we often look to adults to share their experiences. Rather than taking an unbiased approach that includes the perspective of a child, we rely on assumptions that can lead to outcomes based on misunderstandings and misinterpretations. Many children are taught to sit by the wayside without an opportunity to share their valid opinion on the matters that concern their own life. The experiences described by French help to illustrate the importance of listening. Every individual deserves to share her story because in a sense a listener validates her experiences. I believe that more insights will be gained from listening than from following our own assumptions and ignoring the experience lived by others and told by their personal stories.

Valuing and recognizing the personal experiences of every individual remains imperative in the interactions we share. We have to look beyond the superficial actions, beyond our initial interpretations to begin to understand that personal stories provide further insights. Although at times we often have good intentions of wanting to help someone, like in French’s story of adults wanting her to see a rainbow, when we force we can hurt more than we help. How can we understand the experiences of others and provide assistance if we fail to listen to their stories? A raised awareness that incorporates the inclusion of personal stories encourages less about what we want and more about what others need. Personal stories and experiences make the invisible visible to a willing listener.


Reading 34, French, S., “Can You See the Rainbow?” The Roots of Denial

Blog Post 13: Change the system or the individual?

The education systems and healthcare systems in place in our society tend to support middle-class families and upper-class families, but fail to provide support and recognize the inequitable treatment of individuals in working-class and poor families. In Reading 30, Lareau and Weininger explore the different beliefs and practices associated with child rearing in middle-class families and working-class and poor families. According to Lareau and Weininger the approach of middle-class families involve "concerted cultivation, according to which parents view it as their duty to actively foster the development of their children’s potential skills and talents. By contrast... working class and poor child rearing conforms to a logic of the accomplishment of natural growth, according to which parents assume that if they provide their children with love, feed and clothe them, and keep them safe, the children will grow and thrive spontaneously" (p. 292). The two different approaches impact children in middle school years, high school years, and college years. Lareau and Weininger discuss the difficulties of applying to colleges without the resources provided by informed parents. Since the higher education system is designed for middle-class families, it upholds the inequitable treatment of individuals from working-class and poor families through the application process. Similarly, in Reading 31, Reuss describes the link between social class and life expectancy. According to Reuss, “lower spending on public hospitals, schools, and other basic services does not affect wealthy people’s lives expectancies very much, but it affects poor peoples life expectancies a great deal” (p. 303). Individuals that have resources and access to education and healthcare often do not need additional assistance, but without their support, individuals that do need these types of social programs will not have them. Rather than focusing on individual needs, we as a society have to develop and implement education systems and healthcare systems that support all individuals regardless of their social class. In a sense, everyone’s well-being is our well-being.

As I read the articles I began to think about my own experiences as I embarked on the college application process. The process began as my parents and I looked at books that described different colleges and then we compiled a list of colleges to visit. After we narrowed the selection down to five colleges we headed off on a road trip to visit each one. Throughout the process, my parents spoke with friends and relatives for insights about the application process. As I narrowed my search down even further I began the paper portion of the application process and my parents read and revised my application essays. At that time, I thought that my experiences were similar to any other student applying for colleges. While reading the article written by Lareau and Weininger I began to see many similarities between my experience and the experience of the middle-class families that were interviewed. The college application system supported my experience, but without the support and resources provided by my parents I believe that the process would be much more daunting.

Inequitable treatment remains present in many of the systems in society today. If we know that these systems do not support all individuals then why can’t we change their structure? As we recognize the different beliefs and practices associated with child rearing, why can’t we create an equitable structure that addresses diverse needs? Rather than changing individuals to meet the requirements of the system, I believe that we need to change and adapt the system to accommodate the needs of every individual.

Reading 30, Lareau, A. & Weininger, E. B., Class and Transition to Adulthood

Reading 31, Reuss, A., Cause of Death: Inequality

Saturday, July 12, 2014

Blog Post 12: Identity- Race

As we categorize individuals based on their race, we often fail to acknowledge a definition of race that extends beyond skin color. In reading 22, Rodriguez describes the complexity of the construction of racial identity. Although “many Latinos view the question of race as a question of culture, national origin, and socialization rather than simply biological or genetic ancestry or color” (Rodriguez, p. 238), in the United States “genealogical-biological criteria have generally dominated thinking about race” (Rodriguez, p. 238). The attributes that combine to create an individual’s racial identity relies on the definition used to describe racial identity. Similarly, our interactions with one another depend upon our own definition of racial identity. McLeod discusses her experiences of people questioning her race with hopes to connect with her on the personal level of racial identity, but their assumptions lead to further disconnect because of her mixed racial identity. The superficial attributes of racial categorization used to relate to one another remains problematic and fails to recognize that identity resides in something deeper than skin color. Since individual characteristics like race will always exist, it is the way that we talk about it and construct it that will allow us to better understand this component of identity.

While reading the two articles I began to think about how our definitions of racial identity become ingrained and without an alternative perspective we may continue to view racial identity the ways we have been taught. As McLeod described her experiences of individuals attempting to relate to her through their own racial identity, I thought about how we often use appearances to find and connect with people similar to ourselves. When in unfamiliar situations we often base our assumptions on outward appearances. Take for example the first day of school, elementary school, middle school, high school, or college, as we find a seat many of us look for someone to connect with, an identity similar to our own that we can create a safe and familiar space in an unfamiliar environment. When our assumptions turn out to be false it seems as though the connections no longer exist, but as McLeod points out the same person remains. Can we move beyond superficial assumptions and form connections based on something deeper? If so, we need the opportunity to move beyond face value, time to recognize our differences but find connections in our differences through a new perspective of racial identity.

As we move beyond our own ideas about racial identity we can begin to delve deeper and understand the true identity of one another. No longer does racial identity require a biological analysis, it can incorporate much more. As we look at racial identity in this new way, we may be able to extend our new perspective on other forms of difference to explore new meanings. Multiple beliefs and perspectives surround every idea and it is my job to find new ways to look, gaining a deeper understanding of myself and every other person that inhabits this world. Although I have been raised and accustomed to certain beliefs there are always more that I can add to see the big picture more clearly.


Reading 22, Rodriguez, C. E. Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure

Reading 23, McLeod, J. Everybody’s Ethnic Enigma

Blog Post 11: Identity- Sex/Gender

The complexities of sex and gender often become overlooked through the simplification of each exhibited by two distinct and separate categories, man or woman and masculine or feminine. In Reading 9, Kimmel discusses the common misconception of the inherent differences of men and women described by two theories, the nature theory and the nurture theory, that result in gender differences. The differences described in these two theories fail to acknowledge that differences amongst all men and the the differences amongst all women are far more extreme than the differences between men and women. When we begin to recognize the complexities of the concept of gender it “must be seen as an ever-changing fluid assemblage of meaning and behaviors” (Kimmel, p. 118). Kimmel believes that as society addresses gender inequality, such a dialogue will grow to include all differences (racial, ethnicity, etc. ) encouraging individuals to acknowledge the similarities amongst one another while recognizing and celebrating the unique traits of each individual. In reading 10, Dreger describes the complexity of categorizing and assessing the sex of an individual. Although physical appearances exhibit common attributes associated with one sex, “the biology of sex is a lot more complicated” (Dreger, p.123). Dreger discusses the analysis of an individual’s sex through the story of Caster Semenya, an athlete investigated to determine her sex. Contrary to the common belief that sex is easily determined and categorized as man or woman, in order to categorize Semenya’s sex the investigators will “have to decide which of the dozens of characteristics of sex matter to them” (Dreger, p. 124). When we look outside of the categories used to describe an individual’s sex and gender and begin to see the complexities of both, we develop a deeper understanding of each individual’s identity that leads to equitable treatment of all. 

While reading the two articles I begin to question why we need to distinguish the difference between men and women, masculinity and femininity. As we recognize that sex and gender are complex like many categories, we may begin to acknowledge attributes of an individual without relying on the category she has been placed in. In the case of Caster Semenya, I question whether we can we really reprimand an individual because she has a trait that allows her to run quickly. If every individual is different with different abilities, abilities that are often harnessed and used, why not encourage traits that allow individuals to excel? Dreger questions “where do we draw the line between men and women in athletics?” (p. 124), I question that I believe requires a new way of looking and determining sex.  Additionally, how can we force someone into a category that shapes their identity? I believe that we need to move beyond the strict categories of man or woman, masculine or feminine to allow individuals to embody an identity that they personally develop that is recognized by society. 

Categories do not encompass the complexity of an individual’s identity. If we can recognize these categories as a continuum we may have a better understanding of our similarities and our differences without placing each on a hierarchical scale. As we move away from distinct categories we may allow individuals to assign their own identity, rather than relying on scientific analysis to do so.


Reading 9, Kimmel, M. S. The Gendered Society

Reading 10, Dreger, A. Where’s the Rulebook for Sex Verification?

Sunday, July 6, 2014

Blog Post 10: Identity

Identities are determined by both biological and physical attributes and often established by those in power. In Reading 4, Garroutte discusses the definition of the native american identity from the perspective of native americans and the US government through blood quantum, “or degree of Indian ancestry” (p. 66). According to Garroutte, “far from being held to a one-drop rule, Indians are generally required—both by law and by popular opinion— to establish rather high blood quanta in order for their claims to racial identity to be accepted as meaningful” (p. 70). Rather than forming one’s own racial identity through personal perspective and choice, it becomes determined by science benefitting those in power. While individuals only need a hint of “black blood” (Garroutte, p. 70) to be considered African American, American Indians are required to contain “high blood quanta” (Garroutte, p. 70) to prove their American Indian identity. The different qualifications for each racial identity exhibits the inconsistencies in the categorization of racial identities. In contrast to the racial identity of African American and American Indian, White remains the normal and homogeneous racial identity that qualifies everyone else as other. In Reading 6, Frankenberg discusses that “whiteness and Americanness both stood as normative and exclusive categories in relation to which other cultures were identified and marginalized” (p. 90). As we recognize the difficulties and harm that result from racial identity qualifications and categorizations we may begin to realize that identity can be determined by personal perspectives rather than scientific analysis.

While reading the two articles I began to think, how can someone else determine my own identity? Do appearances and blood lines determine who we are? How does this categorization of racial identity affect individuals that are adopted into families? In Garroutte’s article, she discusses one example of a child adopted by an Anishnabe man and raised in his culture. Although the child adopted the racial identity of her family, the lack of biological evidence resulted in a lack of recognition by some individuals. According to Gourette, “the U.S. government allows for the assignment of blood quantum only to biological descendants of Indian people, Canada allows for the naturalization of non-Native children through adoption” (p. 68). When racial identity is accepted through adoption in one country and not in another I believe that the construction of racial identity requires attention and discussion. Why do we have to categorize our own identity through biological and physical attributes? Isn’t our identity something more, isn’t our identity our own to determine?

The readings have emphasized the importance of remaining critical of how identities, my own identity and the identities of others, are constructed, who they are constructed by, and why they are constructed. Once we can recognize the elements that comprise identity in our own society, we can look outside of socially constructed identities and look closer at personally constructed identities. If we continue to only acknowledge the biological and physical components of identity we fail to acknowledge true identity, the way individuals see themselves.

Reading 4, Garroutte, E. M., Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America

Reading 6, Frankenberg, R., Whiteness as an “Unmarked” Cultural Category

Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Blog Post 9: Stereotyping

Stereotyping leads to discriminatory actions that promote the division of individuals based on the socially constructed value of specific attributes. According to Pratt, “the process of racial classification would continued to be modified until the first half of the twentieth century with the intent being to make the definition of a white person increasingly more exclusive” (p. 443). Even on today’s society, certain attributes are held in high esteem while others are deemed inferior.  As discussed by Wu, problems of racial generalization lies in that “people can be arranged by racial groups, and, furthermore, that the differences between racial groups are more significant than either the similarities between racial groups or the differences within them” (p. 375). As we categorize individuals by traits that seem to be distinct, we fail to realize the complexities exhibited by each individual. Stereotyping, whether describing a group of individuals in a negative or positive light becomes problematic. Pratt describes the inequitable laws that regarded interracial marriage illegal a little over fifty years ago while Wu discusses the negative affects of the seemingly positive stereotypes, smart, polite, and family oriented, associated with Asian Americans even today. In both cases, generalizing encouraged the elevation of categories, the white race, and suggests the inferiority of others. While stereotyping continues to divide individuals we will fail to recognize the similarities we have as human beings and the differences that make each of us unique.

While reading the articles I began to think about numerous experiences I have had encountering preconceived ideas associated with specific individuals. Often, generalizations lead to a specific treatment and interaction. If someone is known for engaging in positive actions, even if they engage in detrimental actions, the individual is often associated with the positive actions. Similarly, if someone is perceived as engaging in a negative or destructive actions, the individual is associated with negative actions. During student teaching I can remember a conversation I had with one student. The student often made joking remarks in class and enjoyed spending time socializing with friends. One day in his english class, the student was walking near the teacher’s desk and then returned to his seat. The teacher had been circulating within the classroom and when she returned to her desk, her computer no longer worked. The student told me that since he was known as a jokester, the teacher automatically assumed that he caused the computer malfunction. Although the student said that he did not touch the computer, the teacher remained adamant in her initial beliefs. As the student talked to my mentor teacher and me he continued to say that he was not responsible. By automatically assuming the students guilt, because of prior experiences and a preconceived notion that the student was a trouble maker no matter what he said, he will always be a trouble maker in his english teacher’s eyes. In the art room we had seen positive sides to the student and we believed the story he told us.

An awareness of generalizing and reflecting on how we react because of preconceived ideas remains imperative in education and in our daily lives. Simplifications of individuals fail to recognize their innate complexities. Whether stereotyping incorporates positive or negative attributes it remains detrimental to individuals. As we recognize individuals and their actions without preconceived ideas we address and empower individuals rather than the beliefs we associate with them.

Reading 39, Wu, F. The Model Minority: Asian American “Success” as a Race Relations Failure

Reading 44, Pratt, R. A. Crossing the Color Line: A Historical Assessment and Personal Narrative of Loving v. Virginia

Blog Post 8: Perspectives

Within a world where perspectives are formed from personal experiences, alternative realities remain present if we have the ability to look outside of our own perspective to see from the perspective of others. Wimsatt discusses his perspective as a wealthy individual, using his resources to contribute to the world. His article provides a new perspective of wealthy individuals that look outside of their own lives to contribute to grassroots organizations. As Wimsatt discusses his attempt to connect wealthy individuals with grassroots organizations he suggests that individuals use the resources they have to contribute. Taking the view of an alternative perspective remains an essential asset in positively contributing to society.  According to Kivel, “in order to create contexts where white people and people of color can work together to challenge more fundamental forms of racism, we need to be able to talk to each other about the ways we talk to each other” (p.516). Since the way we communicate our feelings is often cultivated by deep rooted problems, by solely addressing the behavior we fail to recognize the problem of racial discrimination throughout history. A similar misconception about the complexities of identity is discussed by Sengupta. Identities help to form our perspective of how we view the world and Sengupta believes that “all of us are implicated somewhere in our histories or in the histories of our ancestors as victims and as aggressors” (p. 520). As we realize the many realities that co-construct the reality we live in, we can be aware and unite to address the deep rooted problems in the world today.

When reading the articles, I began to think about the multiple realities that become extruded from a single event. The way we construct our perspective relies on our personal experiences. Our identities are complex and I agree with Sengupta that at some point in history our own self or our families have been the victim and have been the aggressor. I think that once we acknowledge this duality we can recognize the similarities that we embody, we have all been the victim and we have all been the aggressor, and we can better understand our own actions as well as the actions of others.

Rather than relying on initial impressions and appearances I have come to realize the importances of recognizing the complexities that reside within individuals and communities. If we can take the time to recognize and try to understand the perspective of someone that embodies different attributes than ourself, we can better understand their actions. As we acknowledge difference we can better communicate and form productive relationships with individuals different from ourself. Rather than accepting our personal perceptions of the events that take place, it remains imperative that we view events through multiple lenses. A complex world filled with complex individuals requires multiple perspectives to provide a comprehensive view. Once we look outside of ourself we can see truths that we never realized existed.



Reading 53, Wimsatt, W. U. In Defense of Rich Kids 
Reading 54, Kivel, P. Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice

Reading 55, Sengupta, S. I/Me/Mine— Intersectional Identities as Negotiated Minefields 

Thursday, June 26, 2014

Digital Journal 6/24


Blog Post 7: Change

We often think of ourselves as too small and too insignificant to contribute to major changes in the world. In Reading 49, Collins describes multiple individuals taking action against the discriminatory actions taken against them and in the process contributing to anti-discriminatory impact on the much larger level of society. Even though these small actions seemed insignificant at the time, they have paved the way for anti-discriminatory laws today. Wilson discusses a very similar ripple affect that began with Rosa Parks and continues with individuals with disabilities. The public transportation bus symbolizes a combination of equitable opportunities at work and recreational activities, the ability to stop a public transportation bus that discriminates has empowered individuals to organize social change. Wilson concludes that commemorating Rosa Parks requires the inclusion of equal access to every individual. In Reading 52, Johnson examines the myths associated with the silence that helps to continue the discriminatory beliefs and actions within society. Johnson believes that “it’s not unreasonable to want to make a difference, but if we have to see the final result of what we do, then we can’t be part of change that’s too gradual and long term to allow that” (p. 504). As we find confidence in the notion that each action contributes and we may never know what actions may follow, we can live our lives and pave new paths toward a society that promotes equity and admires diversity.

While reading the articles I began to think about one hot summer day that I spent on the beach. As I sat on a chair in the sun I heard two middle school aged boys talking about the hundreds of jellyfish that had washed up on the shore. They talked about how the jellyfish would sting everyone, so as the jellyfish remained helpless on the beach the boys used their shovels and punctured them with hopes that they would never sting again. Living in Delaware all my life has allowed me to learn about the animals that live close by in the ocean. When I was little I was always taught that moon jellies were harmless creatures that drifted through the water. As I saw the two young boys killing the jellyfish I followed my instinct and quickly ran over to them. I talked with the boys as I picked up a moon jellyfish and showed that that they did not sting, they were just relaxing and sadly they didn’t have the ability to find their way back to the water once they were washed ashore. The boys said that they would now be in charge of putting the jellyfish back into the water where they belonged. As I walked along the beach with the boys placing the jellyfish back in the water, I overheard one of the boys talking to a friend. He said how it was extremely important to get all of the jellyfish back in the water because they did not sting, they were simply floating along. That day turned into a jellyfish rescue day, not just a day of sitting on the beach.

After reading the articles for the class I feel enlightened and debilitated by the tremendous amount of discrimination within our society. I feel more confident after the final readings that subtle actions can have an impact. Although I may not see immediate change, as I take small steps I can believe that change is in progress. I can only focus on my own actions with hopes of paving new paths that positively affect the actions of others. Rather than changing personal beliefs in an oppressive manner, providing new paths allows all individuals to determine a path that parallels their personal beliefs. When I realize that I can focus on my own actions, reactions, and interactions with others change becomes possible.

Reading 49, Collins, G. Lilly’s Big Day
Reading 50, Wilson, C. The Other Movement That Rosa Parks Inspired: By Sitting Down, She Made Room for the Disabled

Reading 52, Johnson, A. G. What Can We Do? Becoming Part of the Solution. 

Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Blog Post 6: Popular Culture

We often construct a personal perspective through the beliefs and ideas presented to us. Popular culture presents ideas that directly affect our own perspective of how we view the world. As discussed by Kendall, “in a mass-mediated culture such as ours, the media do not simply mirror society; rather, they help to shape it and to create cultural perceptions” (p. 449). Popular culture displays unrealistic portrayals of the wealthy, the middle class, the working class, and the poor by idealizing the life of the wealthy, supporting the middle class, and devaluing the working class and the poor. As we accept the beliefs presented by popular culture we fail to recognize alternative perspectives that incorporate the experiences of many. Similarly, the article written by Harris and Carbado describe a color-blind frame from which we view individuals that fails to acknowledge the subtle actions of racism present today. According to Harris and Carbado, “racial frames shape our perception of the facts” (p. 457). The way we interpret images and interactions depends upon how the information is presented. Garland-Thomson discusses the concept of disability cultivated through popular culture making it something to be fixed rather than an individual trait that exhibits variety. As we re-envision the way we think about disability, Garland-Thomson believes that there will be positive changes in the way individuals with disabilities are treated. Our perceptions are affected by the perceptions of others and if we can change the way we look at an individual or a situation it can positively change the interactions we engage in and the perspective from which we view the world.

As I read the three articles I began to think about the images within magazines, newspapers, and advertisements that convey multiple meanings to a viewer. I turn the page of the local newspaper and find an ad for eye glasses depicting a young white woman with a flawless face, perfect long blond hair, and beautiful eyes and next to it an add for a pontoon boat that displays a white couple standing next to one another drinking wine with a small dog sitting alongside. Both articles show a lifestyle, one that supports money and ideas about perfection. At first thought I begin to think how I could see myself in the images and how each could enhance my life, but after some thought and a second glance I begin to think why? Why is it important? Who has decided that this means beauty or the ideal lifestyle? Each image helps to propel a specific meaning and idea. The preconceived notions associated with specific imagery generate ideas that often sway and help to form our own perspective if we let them.

Images are extremely powerful. Visual literacy remains an essential tool in the world today, allowing a viewer to decipher the meaning of images and the intent of the author. Rather than “buying in” on an idea, looking deeper to discover the meaning and the reason behind it is crucial. As I think about the imagery that constantly bombards us today in newspapers, magazines, TV advertisements, and TV shows to name only a few I begin to question whether we automatically assume truth or if we look deeper? I think that when our perspective is dwindled down to emulate those given to us, our choice and individuality is taken away. As we become more aware of the intended messages we can construct our own perspective and decide how popular culture will shape us and our own actions.

Reading 45, Kendall, D., Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America
Reading 46, Harris, C. L. & Carbado, D. W., Loot or Find: Fact or Framed?
Reading 48, Garland-Thomson, R., Disability and Representation

Thursday, June 19, 2014

Blog Post 5: Race

Although race has played a central role in our history, today our society places the concept of race on the back burner with hopes of creating a color-blind society. The action of disregarding race to enhance equal opportunities promotes discrimination through avoidance. Gladwell discusses the role that our unconscious plays with regards to the Implicit Association Test. Within the IAT, participants linked words to images or other words to choose associations, uncovering unconscious beliefs about race. Gladwell states, “the disturbing thing about the test is that it shows that our unconscious attitudes may be utterly incompatible with our stated conscious values” (p. 354). The problem remains in the actions driven by our unconscious and the thoughts that address situations requiring split second thinking. In the article written by Bronson and Merryman, the study uncovered the harm in ignoring explicit discussions about race with young children. A color-blind perspective does not exist and without a guide to race, children make their own assumptions and create their own categories. In an additional article, Wise describes the current beliefs centered around the presidential election of Barack Obama that illuminates the difference between overt racism and the now more widely used subtle racism. Many believe that Obama’s election into office clearly demonstrates an end to racism, but the author believes that it is far from over. Throughout history, achievements of individual black americans have not changed societal beliefs about all black americans, only a selective few which has failed to provide equitable opportunities for all. All three articles describe a racism that hides in the unconscious and the unspoken while discriminatory actions still prevail. 

As I read the three articles I began to think about many situations that I have experienced when adults hush the questions of young children. Rather than acknowledging questions that arise from seemingly awkward situations, a quiet hush quickly quiets and discourages the uncomfortable discussion that could arise. As we teach children to push ideas out of public conversation how can we expect them to rationalize the concept of difference and equity? Questions arise to inform the unknown, otherwise beliefs and thoughts remains understandings based on personal assumptions. Why do we assign awkward or uncomfortable feelings with conversations? How can we change our thinking to embrace questions and uncertainty?

Since no action results in an action, the actions and beliefs of individuals cannot remain neutral. When uncomfortable and unfamiliar situations arise, rather than trying to back away we need to understand that every action is meaningful. Actions that step away from discussions and interactions disregard and ignore. As we reflect on our actions we can become aware of our unconscious feelings, the actions we engage in, and why we engage in such actions. Explicit discussions about race remain imperative to encouraging questions and discussions about the unknown to enlighten previous assumptions. Discussion encourages the inclusion of diverse perspectives and experiences. As we recognize the importance of approaching the unknown with explicit and comprehensive discussion rather than polite conversation we may be able to develop unconscious thinking based on conscious values that utilize multiple perspectives rather than preconceived assumptions. 

Reading 36, Gladwell, M. Blink in Black and White
Reading 37, Bronson, P., & Merryman, A. See Baby Discriminate
Reading 38, Wise, T. Between Barack and a Hard Place

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Digital Journal 6/17

"What difference does difference make?" (Rosenblum & Travis, p. 332)


Tuesday, June 17, 2014

Blog Post 4: Sexual Orientation

Definitions and assumptions within society combine to form perspectives that shape the identities of individuals. According to Seidman, “we fashion identities by drawing on a culture that already associates identities with certain behaviors, places, and things” (p. 269). Our identities are based on the perceptions of others. Seidman discusses two components of identity, core identity as a central element of the public presentation and identity threads that only become exposed in certain situations. Societal assumptions encourage or discourage identity attributes and affect the treatment of individuals. Assumptions about an individual are often accompanied by assumptions about the treatment of the individual that leads to discriminatory actions, tolerance, or equity. Within Reading 28, Pascoe discusses the assumptions that surround the word fag in a high school environment. Although many male students used the word jokingly, it cultivated violent and discriminatory actions causing harm to individual students. In Reading 29, Rothblum discusses societal assumptions about sexual orientation that promote an either/or approach rather than a complex continuum. If we fashion our identities on societal beliefs, we base our identities on assumptions. As we take a closer look by acknowledging and challenging the previous assumptions created by society, an identity comprised of complex continuums may evolve into a holistic self recognized and supported by society.

When thinking about the definitions and assumptions that cultivate identities, I began to think about a story I was told during the past year. A friend of mine works at a small family farm, milking cows on week nights and weekends. During the week, she works at a high school. During the spring, a student began attending the school and instantly had trouble adjusting to the new school. He displayed disruptive and violent behavior and many teachers began to form opinions about the student. My friend commented how she would like to find a way to reach the young boy, but without a plan she continued to think. One afternoon while milking, the boy walked through the farm, making negative comments about the smell of the farm and the cows near by. Rather than yelling at the boy or authoritatively confronting him, my friend discussed how at many farms cows are viewed as objects, but at this farm the cows are loved and become an essential part of the family. She later saw the boy nuzzling with the cows. As she shared her own perspective, one that the young boy may have never encountered, he seemed to change his perspective drastically and form a relationship with the cows and the teacher. 

The readings and my experience emphasize the importance of acknowledging the assumptions and the definitions used daily that impact and form the identities of individuals. Since our assumptions shape the identity of others, it remains imperative that we acknowledge the power we have when we interact with one another. When we look at individuals through a lens of either/or we miss many nuances. Although it is often difficult to form a new perspective, when given the opportunity to see the world and those that inhabit it in a new light we may adopt it. Rather than simplifying our perspective we need to extend our beliefs to meet the diversified world we live in and support and celebrate each person’s true identity.

Reading 27, Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life, Seidman, S. 
Reading 28, Dude, You’re a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia, Pascoe, C. J.

Reading 29, Sexual Orientation and Sex in Women’s Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues, Rothblum, E. D.

Thursday, June 12, 2014

Blog Post 3: Sex and Gender

Ideologies within society influence social practices and actions, but often fail to recognize the negative consequences that accompany them. Beliefs about family values and masculinity remain central contributors to the interaction of individuals within society. According to Collins, “the traditional family ideal lies in its dual function as an ideological construction and as a fundamental principle of social organization” (p. 246). The way we structure society constructs beliefs about gender, race, class, and nation that drive the actions of individuals. These beliefs often become so ingrained that they are mistaken for scientific truths and in support of a particular lifestyle.These general ideas we have about family and masculinity shape the discriminatory actions in society that translate into discriminatory actions of individuals. Collins asserts, “instead of engaging in endless criticism, reclaiming the language of family for democratic ends and transforming the very conception of family itself might provide a more useful approach” (p. 252). As beliefs in society evolve to provide equitable opportunities for all, the concept of family and masculinity will have to evolve as well. 

After reading the two articles I began to think about how society overtly instills beliefs, but rather than accepting beliefs as a perspective from which to view the world, they become accepted as truths. When a particular lifestyle constantly bombards individuals through movies, advertisements, and the structure of governmental funding (just to name a few) it  becomes ingrained. When society has created an inequitable structure that promotes a specific belief it is often difficult to take an alternative perspective. The more I think about the negative consequences that accompany the beliefs centered around traditional family and masculinity I realize that merely accepting popular beliefs becomes a discriminatory action. An awareness remains imperative in change that is necessary for anti-discriminatory actions and beliefs held by both individuals and society.

When thinking about discriminatory actions taken by individuals, I believe that rather than solely focusing on changing the actions of an individual we need to look at the beliefs of society that lead to such actions. This notion ties into the framework essay that emphasizes the importance of acknowledging and understanding diverse perspectives. Understanding diverse perspectives requires uncovering the deep rooted beliefs and societal norms that drive actions. Societal norms often set up many individuals to treat and be treated inequitably. As discussed by Beneke, “it would appear that at least some of the evils of the world, e.g., sexism, facism, homophobia, and racism, are, in varying degrees, then, ways that men prove their manhood” (p. 256). The current concept of masculinity sets men and boys up to partake in harmful and inequitable actions in order to fulfill beliefs about masculinity held in our current society. We have to think about the consequences of our beliefs and actions as individuals and as a society to promote equitable treatment for all.  


Reading 24, Collins, P. H., It’s All in the Family: Intersections of Gender, Race, and Nation

Reading 25, Beneke, T., Proving Manhood 

Friday, June 6, 2014

Blog Post 2: What is Social Class?

The term social class often evokes imagery of clothing, cars, and houses but beyond material goods social class embodies relationships of power amongst individuals.  As discussed by Zweig, “our individuality and personal life chances are shaped—limited or enhance—by the economic and social class in which we have grown up and in which we exist as adults” (p. 130). Zweig describes three distinct classes, the “working class”, the “middle class”, and the “capitalist class” with boundaries determined by the “degree of autonomy and control” (p. 132). The division in classes does not result in an equal distribution of wealth. Although the income of individuals in the top 1% have increased drastically it has remained constant for the middle class, adding to the inequality of wealth distribution that extends beyond the individual (The Economist). 

Social class does not only affect one individual, but entire generations of families. McNamee and Miller describe an “intergenerational relay race” that places the children of wealthy individuals near the finish line and children born in low socio-economic status families far behind all others. Inheritance triumphs over merit in this race. Parents often pass their wealth to their children through money transactions as well as experiences. Paying for college, contributing to life changing events, making connections by networking, and preventative healthcare all contribute to a child’s head start in the race called life. 

While reading the article I am sitting on the couch and reflecting on the fact that I am an adult moving back with my parents until I can find a steady income. At first thought, my parents offered me my old room, many parents would do that, wouldn’t they? As I look deeper into my current living arrangement I realize that they are able and willing to offer me food, shelter, and water. Able is critical. Leaving school, like many I assume, I am afraid of what the future will bring, but I know that I have support that will deter any downward spirals. If I stumble into unfortunate events I have aid, a concept that while growing up I think I remained unaware of until I began college and realized that the support provided by my family was different than some of my friends from both ends of the spectrum. 

As I acknowledge the support I am given and how it propels me forward, I also acknowledge that the support I receive differs drastically amongst individuals. Looking back, many of my life endeavors and opportunities tie to my family. Getting to know myself as an individual relies on the act of reflecting on my past and current experiences, all tied to the support I receive. When looking at these connections I begin to think about how individuals are affected by the connections to their family and their community. Yes, an individual is an individual, but the identity of an individual must incorporate the impact of connections.

I become frustrated when thinking about the inequality of the distribution of wealth. When hearing about wealth as always a sign of hard work I begin to think about how most wealth stems from inheritance. Similarly, the notion that a lack of wealth results from a lack of work is unfair and untrue. As a future educator I ask, how can we move students further along this relay race track? I think it may begin with acknowledging the connections we each have as well as an awareness that everyone’s connections may present different strengths and difficulties. By developing a deeper understanding of the concept of social class we can assess ourselves and the social class structure to make strides for a better future.

Reading 12, Zweig, M., What’s Class Got to Do with It?
Reading 13, The Economist, More or Less Equal?

Reading 14, McNamee, S.J. & Miller, R. K., The Silver Spoon: Inheritance and the Staggered Start

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Blog Post 1: What is Disability?


At first glance the category of disability seems valid in assessing ability through scientific methods in order to assist individuals that need additional support. The problem lies within the very word of disability, conveying a detrimental attribute of an individual. When looking a little closer I begin to realize that the term, disability, is socially constructed and dependent upon an individual’s surrounding environment. A specific characteristic labeled as a disability in one environment does not necessarily translate to a disability in a different environment. As discussed by Oliver, “impairments are not randomly distributed throughout the world but are culturally produced” (p. 169). Disabilities depend upon the perspective of the individual and the society. Within Mundy's article, two Deaf women did not view deafness as a disability, instead they viewed it as a trait and an essential component of their identity that they hoped to share with their future child. As discussed by Lane, “difference and diversity not only have evolutionary significance, but...are a major part of what gives life its richness and meaning; ethnic diversity is a basic human good”(p. 189). The label of disability depends upon perspective and either relies on the notion that it requires a cure or becomes accepted as one of the many traits that comprise an individual's identity.

 When reading the articles I began to think about how different attributes excel in specific environments. The problem lies within an environment that is created and catered toward a certain trait or characteristic. I live in a small town that is beginning to grow and grow each year. With the growth comes an increase in population and traffic. The transportation systems within the community favored individuals with cars. Very few bus routes and short bike paths discouraged alternate travel opportunities. Recently, the state constructed bike paths that connect many of the small towns. The bike paths may be used for bikes, runners, walkers to name just a few modes of transportation. A few years ago the community supported car transportation, presenting difficulties to individuals without a car. Now, as the community has acknowledge different forms of transportation they make transportation accessible to many more individuals. Rather than placing the responsibility on the individual to change and adapt to the transportation system, the community changed its view and adapted paths that makes transportation accessible to all.

As the term disability often places the problem with the individual, I now recognize that the problem does not reside with the individual, but with the ineffective structure and narrow perspective constructed by the society. As discussed in the personal account of Shaw, “as long as others are seeing me as able, I feel and act more able” (p. 171). Why not make all individuals feel able by adapting the environment rather than merely suggesting to fix the individual? I believe that a change must begin with a collective consciousness that acknowledges that disability lies in a perspective constructed by society. Acknowledging differences as strengths by emphasizing positive attributes begins with a raised awareness that requires reevaluating old beliefs and reflecting on new ideas to see each individual as able.



Reading 18: Oliver, M. Disability Definitions:The Politics of Meaning 

Personal Account: Shaw, H. L. Invisibly Disabled
Reading 19: Mundy, L. A World of Their Own
Reading 20: Lane, H. Ethnicity, Ethics, and the Deaf-World