Tuesday, June 17, 2014

Blog Post 4: Sexual Orientation

Definitions and assumptions within society combine to form perspectives that shape the identities of individuals. According to Seidman, “we fashion identities by drawing on a culture that already associates identities with certain behaviors, places, and things” (p. 269). Our identities are based on the perceptions of others. Seidman discusses two components of identity, core identity as a central element of the public presentation and identity threads that only become exposed in certain situations. Societal assumptions encourage or discourage identity attributes and affect the treatment of individuals. Assumptions about an individual are often accompanied by assumptions about the treatment of the individual that leads to discriminatory actions, tolerance, or equity. Within Reading 28, Pascoe discusses the assumptions that surround the word fag in a high school environment. Although many male students used the word jokingly, it cultivated violent and discriminatory actions causing harm to individual students. In Reading 29, Rothblum discusses societal assumptions about sexual orientation that promote an either/or approach rather than a complex continuum. If we fashion our identities on societal beliefs, we base our identities on assumptions. As we take a closer look by acknowledging and challenging the previous assumptions created by society, an identity comprised of complex continuums may evolve into a holistic self recognized and supported by society.

When thinking about the definitions and assumptions that cultivate identities, I began to think about a story I was told during the past year. A friend of mine works at a small family farm, milking cows on week nights and weekends. During the week, she works at a high school. During the spring, a student began attending the school and instantly had trouble adjusting to the new school. He displayed disruptive and violent behavior and many teachers began to form opinions about the student. My friend commented how she would like to find a way to reach the young boy, but without a plan she continued to think. One afternoon while milking, the boy walked through the farm, making negative comments about the smell of the farm and the cows near by. Rather than yelling at the boy or authoritatively confronting him, my friend discussed how at many farms cows are viewed as objects, but at this farm the cows are loved and become an essential part of the family. She later saw the boy nuzzling with the cows. As she shared her own perspective, one that the young boy may have never encountered, he seemed to change his perspective drastically and form a relationship with the cows and the teacher. 

The readings and my experience emphasize the importance of acknowledging the assumptions and the definitions used daily that impact and form the identities of individuals. Since our assumptions shape the identity of others, it remains imperative that we acknowledge the power we have when we interact with one another. When we look at individuals through a lens of either/or we miss many nuances. Although it is often difficult to form a new perspective, when given the opportunity to see the world and those that inhabit it in a new light we may adopt it. Rather than simplifying our perspective we need to extend our beliefs to meet the diversified world we live in and support and celebrate each person’s true identity.

Reading 27, Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life, Seidman, S. 
Reading 28, Dude, You’re a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia, Pascoe, C. J.

Reading 29, Sexual Orientation and Sex in Women’s Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues, Rothblum, E. D.

1 comment:

  1. Leah,
    It sounds as though the teachers had formed their opinions about the boy and he responded as they expected. We fit into the roles that are assigned to us. I see this in my classroom, especially in the third grade. These are small groups of students (7-12) that have been together since Kindergarten in a formal setting, and often earlier through playgroups and parental friendships. They don’t need time to get to know each other at the beginning of the year. They already have everyone firmly categorized and in their place. The girl who instigates trouble is watched like a hawk, even by the teachers, and this is where the problem really begins. What if a child is trying to change? What if she has decided that she doesn’t want to play that part anymore? It disrupts the dynamics of the group, and the group pushes back. It is hard for an eight-year-old to battle against the expectations placed on her by the group. I have to watch myself carefully, and I start each year as though the children are strangers to me and to each other, but it is a constant struggle to change group opinions, especially when a child has internalized the identity so firmly.
    Something similar happens when a new child joins the group unexpectedly. Even children have formed their ideas of gender and race, and as teachers we recognize that there are certain types of students who show up in the middle of a school year. I heard someone note in surprise when a foster child was placed in a classroom that she wasn’t on an IEP! I agree that we have to keep being aware of our assumptions so that we don’t misjudge and miscategorize anyone, especially our students. Thanks, Claudia

    ReplyDelete