As I sit here reflecting the question What are the aims of diversity? I must acknowledge that it expands beyond the scope of my perspective and it will continue to evolve throughout my life experiences. Only now can I begin to unpack the concept of diversity with the introduction that I have been given and with a new perspective that I have began to form. This is just the beginning of a new consciousness.
I am an artist familiar with the terms frame and perspective because I use both to narrow a viewer’s focus on an intended subject shown in a particular manner within a painting. The same idea holds true in the media as described by Kendall, “media frames constitute a mental short (schema) that helps us formulate our thoughts” (p. 449). I have used this knowledge to apply to my new understanding of diversity and the categories that used to frame the way I viewed the world. As I look beyond the frame that society has created, I begin to discover that diversity is essentially linked to an identity that requires a continuum of variations not a set of traits that fit within a single frame.
Identities are comprised of traits that are defined and constructed by society. As discussed by Seidman, “identities refer to the way we think of ourselves and the self image we publicly project” (p. 269). Identities are constructed by our own view of ourselves as well as the way we are perceived by others. According to Seidman, “we fashion identities by drawing on a culture that already associates identities with certain behaviors, places, and things” (p. 269), associations created by previous assumptions and categories that fail to acknowledge the complexities of human nature. Take for instance sex, the categorization of an individual into one of two distinct categories, man or woman. In Reading 10, Dreger discusses the investigation determining the sex of the world-champion runner, Caster Semenya, and the difficulties that ensued because of the complexities in determining sex. The level of complexity remains present in sexual orientation, gender, and race, to name just a few categories that are not as cut and dry as they first appear. As we acknowledge the presence of difference, we must also recognize the importance of moving beyond a color-blind approach of ignoring differences. A color-blind approach fails to recognize that individuals incorporate traits that make them unique as well as the ranking system of each trait on a hierarchical scale determined by society that justifies and propels inequitable treatment.
The inequitable treatment of individuals resides in a hierarchical scale created, defined, and upheld by society. As discussed by Rosenblum and Travis (2012), “ideologies confer meaning on difference; they both shape and are shaped by social institutions” (p. 348). As ideologies and social institutions co-construct the meaning of difference, categories isolate specific traits and certain individuals. In Reading 30 Lareau and Weininger explore the impact of different forms of child rearing in middle-class families, working-class families, and poor families with concerns to middle school, high school, and college. The authors suggest that the higher education application process supports middle-class families and “this knowledge, and the associated dispositions, may be viewed as a form of “cultural capitol”—one that is clearly implicated in the long-term persistence of inequality” (p. 301). Similar to the structure of the education systems, the healthcare systems illustrates that “inequity kills and it starts at the bottom” (Reuss, p. 304). Difference does affect the lives of individuals when social programs uphold inequitable treatment through systems used to categorize and propel classifications and discriminate against those that embody traits labeled as inferior.
The aims of diversity are to recognize the complexities of identities, celebrating our individual and unique traits by continually developing new perspectives to view our own identity and the identities of others. A new perspective requires listening, validating the personal experiences of others as much as we validate our own experiences. The invisible becomes visible to an active listener and provides the opportunity to see things differently that move beyond superficial assumptions. A raised awareness assists the ability to critically assess the groupings we use to selectively categorize specific traits and question why they were developed and how they are currently defined to cultivate an understanding that extends beyond what we have been told and are accustomed to hearing. If we have constructed these categories we can mindfully reject them to appreciate the complexity of human life.
As we recognize that we define and construct differences we can become empowered to change the way that we view differences. We can begin by recognizing and remaining conscious of our own actions, modeling and supporting equitable treatment that provides an entry point for others. The question remains, will we make people conform and fit into pre-determined categories or create environments and systems that adapt and address the complexities exhibited by the individual?
I will continue to learn about the complexities of each individual’s identity every day and plan to adapt the environment around me to address and support the needs of the individual. Although I plan to teach art, ideas about diversity can become intertwined within each lesson and each interaction I have in the classroom. I hope to inspire discussions that address differences, encouraging and celebrating dialogue rather than hiding or erasing unfamiliar and uncomfortable topics. As we expose ideas about diversity to students, we may spark ideas and actions that continue beyond the classroom. According to Seidman,“respecting and valuing group differences is a key part of this nation’s identity” (p. 273). As an educator I strive to provide opportunities for students to develop and display a personal identity that incorporates both an individual consciousness and a collective consciousness.
I move forward with a new understanding and appreciation for difference, individual experiences and stories, and an awareness that breaks away from the socially constructed frame. Frames belong around works of art, not personal perspectives from which to view the world. A raised consciousness extends beyond the confines of a frame and continues to grow if encouraged.
References
Rosenblum, K. E., & Travis, T. C. 2012. The meaning of difference: American constructions of race, sex and gender, social class, sexual orientation, and disability. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Reading 10, Dreger, A. Where’s the Rulebook for Sex Verification?
Reading 27, Seidman, S. Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life
Reading 30, Lareau, A., & Weininger, E. B. Class and the Transition to Adulthood
Reading 31, Reuss, A. Cause of Death: Inequality
Reading 45, Kendall, D. Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America