Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Blog Post 9: Stereotyping

Stereotyping leads to discriminatory actions that promote the division of individuals based on the socially constructed value of specific attributes. According to Pratt, “the process of racial classification would continued to be modified until the first half of the twentieth century with the intent being to make the definition of a white person increasingly more exclusive” (p. 443). Even on today’s society, certain attributes are held in high esteem while others are deemed inferior.  As discussed by Wu, problems of racial generalization lies in that “people can be arranged by racial groups, and, furthermore, that the differences between racial groups are more significant than either the similarities between racial groups or the differences within them” (p. 375). As we categorize individuals by traits that seem to be distinct, we fail to realize the complexities exhibited by each individual. Stereotyping, whether describing a group of individuals in a negative or positive light becomes problematic. Pratt describes the inequitable laws that regarded interracial marriage illegal a little over fifty years ago while Wu discusses the negative affects of the seemingly positive stereotypes, smart, polite, and family oriented, associated with Asian Americans even today. In both cases, generalizing encouraged the elevation of categories, the white race, and suggests the inferiority of others. While stereotyping continues to divide individuals we will fail to recognize the similarities we have as human beings and the differences that make each of us unique.

While reading the articles I began to think about numerous experiences I have had encountering preconceived ideas associated with specific individuals. Often, generalizations lead to a specific treatment and interaction. If someone is known for engaging in positive actions, even if they engage in detrimental actions, the individual is often associated with the positive actions. Similarly, if someone is perceived as engaging in a negative or destructive actions, the individual is associated with negative actions. During student teaching I can remember a conversation I had with one student. The student often made joking remarks in class and enjoyed spending time socializing with friends. One day in his english class, the student was walking near the teacher’s desk and then returned to his seat. The teacher had been circulating within the classroom and when she returned to her desk, her computer no longer worked. The student told me that since he was known as a jokester, the teacher automatically assumed that he caused the computer malfunction. Although the student said that he did not touch the computer, the teacher remained adamant in her initial beliefs. As the student talked to my mentor teacher and me he continued to say that he was not responsible. By automatically assuming the students guilt, because of prior experiences and a preconceived notion that the student was a trouble maker no matter what he said, he will always be a trouble maker in his english teacher’s eyes. In the art room we had seen positive sides to the student and we believed the story he told us.

An awareness of generalizing and reflecting on how we react because of preconceived ideas remains imperative in education and in our daily lives. Simplifications of individuals fail to recognize their innate complexities. Whether stereotyping incorporates positive or negative attributes it remains detrimental to individuals. As we recognize individuals and their actions without preconceived ideas we address and empower individuals rather than the beliefs we associate with them.

Reading 39, Wu, F. The Model Minority: Asian American “Success” as a Race Relations Failure

Reading 44, Pratt, R. A. Crossing the Color Line: A Historical Assessment and Personal Narrative of Loving v. Virginia

No comments:

Post a Comment