Sunday, July 6, 2014

Blog Post 10: Identity

Identities are determined by both biological and physical attributes and often established by those in power. In Reading 4, Garroutte discusses the definition of the native american identity from the perspective of native americans and the US government through blood quantum, “or degree of Indian ancestry” (p. 66). According to Garroutte, “far from being held to a one-drop rule, Indians are generally required—both by law and by popular opinion— to establish rather high blood quanta in order for their claims to racial identity to be accepted as meaningful” (p. 70). Rather than forming one’s own racial identity through personal perspective and choice, it becomes determined by science benefitting those in power. While individuals only need a hint of “black blood” (Garroutte, p. 70) to be considered African American, American Indians are required to contain “high blood quanta” (Garroutte, p. 70) to prove their American Indian identity. The different qualifications for each racial identity exhibits the inconsistencies in the categorization of racial identities. In contrast to the racial identity of African American and American Indian, White remains the normal and homogeneous racial identity that qualifies everyone else as other. In Reading 6, Frankenberg discusses that “whiteness and Americanness both stood as normative and exclusive categories in relation to which other cultures were identified and marginalized” (p. 90). As we recognize the difficulties and harm that result from racial identity qualifications and categorizations we may begin to realize that identity can be determined by personal perspectives rather than scientific analysis.

While reading the two articles I began to think, how can someone else determine my own identity? Do appearances and blood lines determine who we are? How does this categorization of racial identity affect individuals that are adopted into families? In Garroutte’s article, she discusses one example of a child adopted by an Anishnabe man and raised in his culture. Although the child adopted the racial identity of her family, the lack of biological evidence resulted in a lack of recognition by some individuals. According to Gourette, “the U.S. government allows for the assignment of blood quantum only to biological descendants of Indian people, Canada allows for the naturalization of non-Native children through adoption” (p. 68). When racial identity is accepted through adoption in one country and not in another I believe that the construction of racial identity requires attention and discussion. Why do we have to categorize our own identity through biological and physical attributes? Isn’t our identity something more, isn’t our identity our own to determine?

The readings have emphasized the importance of remaining critical of how identities, my own identity and the identities of others, are constructed, who they are constructed by, and why they are constructed. Once we can recognize the elements that comprise identity in our own society, we can look outside of socially constructed identities and look closer at personally constructed identities. If we continue to only acknowledge the biological and physical components of identity we fail to acknowledge true identity, the way individuals see themselves.

Reading 4, Garroutte, E. M., Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America

Reading 6, Frankenberg, R., Whiteness as an “Unmarked” Cultural Category

No comments:

Post a Comment