Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Blog Post 13: Change the system or the individual?

The education systems and healthcare systems in place in our society tend to support middle-class families and upper-class families, but fail to provide support and recognize the inequitable treatment of individuals in working-class and poor families. In Reading 30, Lareau and Weininger explore the different beliefs and practices associated with child rearing in middle-class families and working-class and poor families. According to Lareau and Weininger the approach of middle-class families involve "concerted cultivation, according to which parents view it as their duty to actively foster the development of their children’s potential skills and talents. By contrast... working class and poor child rearing conforms to a logic of the accomplishment of natural growth, according to which parents assume that if they provide their children with love, feed and clothe them, and keep them safe, the children will grow and thrive spontaneously" (p. 292). The two different approaches impact children in middle school years, high school years, and college years. Lareau and Weininger discuss the difficulties of applying to colleges without the resources provided by informed parents. Since the higher education system is designed for middle-class families, it upholds the inequitable treatment of individuals from working-class and poor families through the application process. Similarly, in Reading 31, Reuss describes the link between social class and life expectancy. According to Reuss, “lower spending on public hospitals, schools, and other basic services does not affect wealthy people’s lives expectancies very much, but it affects poor peoples life expectancies a great deal” (p. 303). Individuals that have resources and access to education and healthcare often do not need additional assistance, but without their support, individuals that do need these types of social programs will not have them. Rather than focusing on individual needs, we as a society have to develop and implement education systems and healthcare systems that support all individuals regardless of their social class. In a sense, everyone’s well-being is our well-being.

As I read the articles I began to think about my own experiences as I embarked on the college application process. The process began as my parents and I looked at books that described different colleges and then we compiled a list of colleges to visit. After we narrowed the selection down to five colleges we headed off on a road trip to visit each one. Throughout the process, my parents spoke with friends and relatives for insights about the application process. As I narrowed my search down even further I began the paper portion of the application process and my parents read and revised my application essays. At that time, I thought that my experiences were similar to any other student applying for colleges. While reading the article written by Lareau and Weininger I began to see many similarities between my experience and the experience of the middle-class families that were interviewed. The college application system supported my experience, but without the support and resources provided by my parents I believe that the process would be much more daunting.

Inequitable treatment remains present in many of the systems in society today. If we know that these systems do not support all individuals then why can’t we change their structure? As we recognize the different beliefs and practices associated with child rearing, why can’t we create an equitable structure that addresses diverse needs? Rather than changing individuals to meet the requirements of the system, I believe that we need to change and adapt the system to accommodate the needs of every individual.

Reading 30, Lareau, A. & Weininger, E. B., Class and Transition to Adulthood

Reading 31, Reuss, A., Cause of Death: Inequality

No comments:

Post a Comment