The complexities of sex and gender often become overlooked through the simplification of each exhibited by two distinct and separate categories, man or woman and masculine or feminine. In Reading 9, Kimmel discusses the common misconception of the inherent differences of men and women described by two theories, the nature theory and the nurture theory, that result in gender differences. The differences described in these two theories fail to acknowledge that differences amongst all men and the the differences amongst all women are far more extreme than the differences between men and women. When we begin to recognize the complexities of the concept of gender it “must be seen as an ever-changing fluid assemblage of meaning and behaviors” (Kimmel, p. 118). Kimmel believes that as society addresses gender inequality, such a dialogue will grow to include all differences (racial, ethnicity, etc. ) encouraging individuals to acknowledge the similarities amongst one another while recognizing and celebrating the unique traits of each individual. In reading 10, Dreger describes the complexity of categorizing and assessing the sex of an individual. Although physical appearances exhibit common attributes associated with one sex, “the biology of sex is a lot more complicated” (Dreger, p.123). Dreger discusses the analysis of an individual’s sex through the story of Caster Semenya, an athlete investigated to determine her sex. Contrary to the common belief that sex is easily determined and categorized as man or woman, in order to categorize Semenya’s sex the investigators will “have to decide which of the dozens of characteristics of sex matter to them” (Dreger, p. 124). When we look outside of the categories used to describe an individual’s sex and gender and begin to see the complexities of both, we develop a deeper understanding of each individual’s identity that leads to equitable treatment of all.
While reading the two articles I begin to question why we need to distinguish the difference between men and women, masculinity and femininity. As we recognize that sex and gender are complex like many categories, we may begin to acknowledge attributes of an individual without relying on the category she has been placed in. In the case of Caster Semenya, I question whether we can we really reprimand an individual because she has a trait that allows her to run quickly. If every individual is different with different abilities, abilities that are often harnessed and used, why not encourage traits that allow individuals to excel? Dreger questions “where do we draw the line between men and women in athletics?” (p. 124), I question that I believe requires a new way of looking and determining sex. Additionally, how can we force someone into a category that shapes their identity? I believe that we need to move beyond the strict categories of man or woman, masculine or feminine to allow individuals to embody an identity that they personally develop that is recognized by society.
Categories do not encompass the complexity of an individual’s identity. If we can recognize these categories as a continuum we may have a better understanding of our similarities and our differences without placing each on a hierarchical scale. As we move away from distinct categories we may allow individuals to assign their own identity, rather than relying on scientific analysis to do so.
Reading 9, Kimmel, M. S. The Gendered Society
Reading 10, Dreger, A. Where’s the Rulebook for Sex Verification?
No comments:
Post a Comment