Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Blog Post 13: Change the system or the individual?

The education systems and healthcare systems in place in our society tend to support middle-class families and upper-class families, but fail to provide support and recognize the inequitable treatment of individuals in working-class and poor families. In Reading 30, Lareau and Weininger explore the different beliefs and practices associated with child rearing in middle-class families and working-class and poor families. According to Lareau and Weininger the approach of middle-class families involve "concerted cultivation, according to which parents view it as their duty to actively foster the development of their children’s potential skills and talents. By contrast... working class and poor child rearing conforms to a logic of the accomplishment of natural growth, according to which parents assume that if they provide their children with love, feed and clothe them, and keep them safe, the children will grow and thrive spontaneously" (p. 292). The two different approaches impact children in middle school years, high school years, and college years. Lareau and Weininger discuss the difficulties of applying to colleges without the resources provided by informed parents. Since the higher education system is designed for middle-class families, it upholds the inequitable treatment of individuals from working-class and poor families through the application process. Similarly, in Reading 31, Reuss describes the link between social class and life expectancy. According to Reuss, “lower spending on public hospitals, schools, and other basic services does not affect wealthy people’s lives expectancies very much, but it affects poor peoples life expectancies a great deal” (p. 303). Individuals that have resources and access to education and healthcare often do not need additional assistance, but without their support, individuals that do need these types of social programs will not have them. Rather than focusing on individual needs, we as a society have to develop and implement education systems and healthcare systems that support all individuals regardless of their social class. In a sense, everyone’s well-being is our well-being.

As I read the articles I began to think about my own experiences as I embarked on the college application process. The process began as my parents and I looked at books that described different colleges and then we compiled a list of colleges to visit. After we narrowed the selection down to five colleges we headed off on a road trip to visit each one. Throughout the process, my parents spoke with friends and relatives for insights about the application process. As I narrowed my search down even further I began the paper portion of the application process and my parents read and revised my application essays. At that time, I thought that my experiences were similar to any other student applying for colleges. While reading the article written by Lareau and Weininger I began to see many similarities between my experience and the experience of the middle-class families that were interviewed. The college application system supported my experience, but without the support and resources provided by my parents I believe that the process would be much more daunting.

Inequitable treatment remains present in many of the systems in society today. If we know that these systems do not support all individuals then why can’t we change their structure? As we recognize the different beliefs and practices associated with child rearing, why can’t we create an equitable structure that addresses diverse needs? Rather than changing individuals to meet the requirements of the system, I believe that we need to change and adapt the system to accommodate the needs of every individual.

Reading 30, Lareau, A. & Weininger, E. B., Class and Transition to Adulthood

Reading 31, Reuss, A., Cause of Death: Inequality

Saturday, July 12, 2014

Blog Post 12: Identity- Race

As we categorize individuals based on their race, we often fail to acknowledge a definition of race that extends beyond skin color. In reading 22, Rodriguez describes the complexity of the construction of racial identity. Although “many Latinos view the question of race as a question of culture, national origin, and socialization rather than simply biological or genetic ancestry or color” (Rodriguez, p. 238), in the United States “genealogical-biological criteria have generally dominated thinking about race” (Rodriguez, p. 238). The attributes that combine to create an individual’s racial identity relies on the definition used to describe racial identity. Similarly, our interactions with one another depend upon our own definition of racial identity. McLeod discusses her experiences of people questioning her race with hopes to connect with her on the personal level of racial identity, but their assumptions lead to further disconnect because of her mixed racial identity. The superficial attributes of racial categorization used to relate to one another remains problematic and fails to recognize that identity resides in something deeper than skin color. Since individual characteristics like race will always exist, it is the way that we talk about it and construct it that will allow us to better understand this component of identity.

While reading the two articles I began to think about how our definitions of racial identity become ingrained and without an alternative perspective we may continue to view racial identity the ways we have been taught. As McLeod described her experiences of individuals attempting to relate to her through their own racial identity, I thought about how we often use appearances to find and connect with people similar to ourselves. When in unfamiliar situations we often base our assumptions on outward appearances. Take for example the first day of school, elementary school, middle school, high school, or college, as we find a seat many of us look for someone to connect with, an identity similar to our own that we can create a safe and familiar space in an unfamiliar environment. When our assumptions turn out to be false it seems as though the connections no longer exist, but as McLeod points out the same person remains. Can we move beyond superficial assumptions and form connections based on something deeper? If so, we need the opportunity to move beyond face value, time to recognize our differences but find connections in our differences through a new perspective of racial identity.

As we move beyond our own ideas about racial identity we can begin to delve deeper and understand the true identity of one another. No longer does racial identity require a biological analysis, it can incorporate much more. As we look at racial identity in this new way, we may be able to extend our new perspective on other forms of difference to explore new meanings. Multiple beliefs and perspectives surround every idea and it is my job to find new ways to look, gaining a deeper understanding of myself and every other person that inhabits this world. Although I have been raised and accustomed to certain beliefs there are always more that I can add to see the big picture more clearly.


Reading 22, Rodriguez, C. E. Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure

Reading 23, McLeod, J. Everybody’s Ethnic Enigma

Blog Post 11: Identity- Sex/Gender

The complexities of sex and gender often become overlooked through the simplification of each exhibited by two distinct and separate categories, man or woman and masculine or feminine. In Reading 9, Kimmel discusses the common misconception of the inherent differences of men and women described by two theories, the nature theory and the nurture theory, that result in gender differences. The differences described in these two theories fail to acknowledge that differences amongst all men and the the differences amongst all women are far more extreme than the differences between men and women. When we begin to recognize the complexities of the concept of gender it “must be seen as an ever-changing fluid assemblage of meaning and behaviors” (Kimmel, p. 118). Kimmel believes that as society addresses gender inequality, such a dialogue will grow to include all differences (racial, ethnicity, etc. ) encouraging individuals to acknowledge the similarities amongst one another while recognizing and celebrating the unique traits of each individual. In reading 10, Dreger describes the complexity of categorizing and assessing the sex of an individual. Although physical appearances exhibit common attributes associated with one sex, “the biology of sex is a lot more complicated” (Dreger, p.123). Dreger discusses the analysis of an individual’s sex through the story of Caster Semenya, an athlete investigated to determine her sex. Contrary to the common belief that sex is easily determined and categorized as man or woman, in order to categorize Semenya’s sex the investigators will “have to decide which of the dozens of characteristics of sex matter to them” (Dreger, p. 124). When we look outside of the categories used to describe an individual’s sex and gender and begin to see the complexities of both, we develop a deeper understanding of each individual’s identity that leads to equitable treatment of all. 

While reading the two articles I begin to question why we need to distinguish the difference between men and women, masculinity and femininity. As we recognize that sex and gender are complex like many categories, we may begin to acknowledge attributes of an individual without relying on the category she has been placed in. In the case of Caster Semenya, I question whether we can we really reprimand an individual because she has a trait that allows her to run quickly. If every individual is different with different abilities, abilities that are often harnessed and used, why not encourage traits that allow individuals to excel? Dreger questions “where do we draw the line between men and women in athletics?” (p. 124), I question that I believe requires a new way of looking and determining sex.  Additionally, how can we force someone into a category that shapes their identity? I believe that we need to move beyond the strict categories of man or woman, masculine or feminine to allow individuals to embody an identity that they personally develop that is recognized by society. 

Categories do not encompass the complexity of an individual’s identity. If we can recognize these categories as a continuum we may have a better understanding of our similarities and our differences without placing each on a hierarchical scale. As we move away from distinct categories we may allow individuals to assign their own identity, rather than relying on scientific analysis to do so.


Reading 9, Kimmel, M. S. The Gendered Society

Reading 10, Dreger, A. Where’s the Rulebook for Sex Verification?

Sunday, July 6, 2014

Blog Post 10: Identity

Identities are determined by both biological and physical attributes and often established by those in power. In Reading 4, Garroutte discusses the definition of the native american identity from the perspective of native americans and the US government through blood quantum, “or degree of Indian ancestry” (p. 66). According to Garroutte, “far from being held to a one-drop rule, Indians are generally required—both by law and by popular opinion— to establish rather high blood quanta in order for their claims to racial identity to be accepted as meaningful” (p. 70). Rather than forming one’s own racial identity through personal perspective and choice, it becomes determined by science benefitting those in power. While individuals only need a hint of “black blood” (Garroutte, p. 70) to be considered African American, American Indians are required to contain “high blood quanta” (Garroutte, p. 70) to prove their American Indian identity. The different qualifications for each racial identity exhibits the inconsistencies in the categorization of racial identities. In contrast to the racial identity of African American and American Indian, White remains the normal and homogeneous racial identity that qualifies everyone else as other. In Reading 6, Frankenberg discusses that “whiteness and Americanness both stood as normative and exclusive categories in relation to which other cultures were identified and marginalized” (p. 90). As we recognize the difficulties and harm that result from racial identity qualifications and categorizations we may begin to realize that identity can be determined by personal perspectives rather than scientific analysis.

While reading the two articles I began to think, how can someone else determine my own identity? Do appearances and blood lines determine who we are? How does this categorization of racial identity affect individuals that are adopted into families? In Garroutte’s article, she discusses one example of a child adopted by an Anishnabe man and raised in his culture. Although the child adopted the racial identity of her family, the lack of biological evidence resulted in a lack of recognition by some individuals. According to Gourette, “the U.S. government allows for the assignment of blood quantum only to biological descendants of Indian people, Canada allows for the naturalization of non-Native children through adoption” (p. 68). When racial identity is accepted through adoption in one country and not in another I believe that the construction of racial identity requires attention and discussion. Why do we have to categorize our own identity through biological and physical attributes? Isn’t our identity something more, isn’t our identity our own to determine?

The readings have emphasized the importance of remaining critical of how identities, my own identity and the identities of others, are constructed, who they are constructed by, and why they are constructed. Once we can recognize the elements that comprise identity in our own society, we can look outside of socially constructed identities and look closer at personally constructed identities. If we continue to only acknowledge the biological and physical components of identity we fail to acknowledge true identity, the way individuals see themselves.

Reading 4, Garroutte, E. M., Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America

Reading 6, Frankenberg, R., Whiteness as an “Unmarked” Cultural Category

Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Blog Post 9: Stereotyping

Stereotyping leads to discriminatory actions that promote the division of individuals based on the socially constructed value of specific attributes. According to Pratt, “the process of racial classification would continued to be modified until the first half of the twentieth century with the intent being to make the definition of a white person increasingly more exclusive” (p. 443). Even on today’s society, certain attributes are held in high esteem while others are deemed inferior.  As discussed by Wu, problems of racial generalization lies in that “people can be arranged by racial groups, and, furthermore, that the differences between racial groups are more significant than either the similarities between racial groups or the differences within them” (p. 375). As we categorize individuals by traits that seem to be distinct, we fail to realize the complexities exhibited by each individual. Stereotyping, whether describing a group of individuals in a negative or positive light becomes problematic. Pratt describes the inequitable laws that regarded interracial marriage illegal a little over fifty years ago while Wu discusses the negative affects of the seemingly positive stereotypes, smart, polite, and family oriented, associated with Asian Americans even today. In both cases, generalizing encouraged the elevation of categories, the white race, and suggests the inferiority of others. While stereotyping continues to divide individuals we will fail to recognize the similarities we have as human beings and the differences that make each of us unique.

While reading the articles I began to think about numerous experiences I have had encountering preconceived ideas associated with specific individuals. Often, generalizations lead to a specific treatment and interaction. If someone is known for engaging in positive actions, even if they engage in detrimental actions, the individual is often associated with the positive actions. Similarly, if someone is perceived as engaging in a negative or destructive actions, the individual is associated with negative actions. During student teaching I can remember a conversation I had with one student. The student often made joking remarks in class and enjoyed spending time socializing with friends. One day in his english class, the student was walking near the teacher’s desk and then returned to his seat. The teacher had been circulating within the classroom and when she returned to her desk, her computer no longer worked. The student told me that since he was known as a jokester, the teacher automatically assumed that he caused the computer malfunction. Although the student said that he did not touch the computer, the teacher remained adamant in her initial beliefs. As the student talked to my mentor teacher and me he continued to say that he was not responsible. By automatically assuming the students guilt, because of prior experiences and a preconceived notion that the student was a trouble maker no matter what he said, he will always be a trouble maker in his english teacher’s eyes. In the art room we had seen positive sides to the student and we believed the story he told us.

An awareness of generalizing and reflecting on how we react because of preconceived ideas remains imperative in education and in our daily lives. Simplifications of individuals fail to recognize their innate complexities. Whether stereotyping incorporates positive or negative attributes it remains detrimental to individuals. As we recognize individuals and their actions without preconceived ideas we address and empower individuals rather than the beliefs we associate with them.

Reading 39, Wu, F. The Model Minority: Asian American “Success” as a Race Relations Failure

Reading 44, Pratt, R. A. Crossing the Color Line: A Historical Assessment and Personal Narrative of Loving v. Virginia

Blog Post 8: Perspectives

Within a world where perspectives are formed from personal experiences, alternative realities remain present if we have the ability to look outside of our own perspective to see from the perspective of others. Wimsatt discusses his perspective as a wealthy individual, using his resources to contribute to the world. His article provides a new perspective of wealthy individuals that look outside of their own lives to contribute to grassroots organizations. As Wimsatt discusses his attempt to connect wealthy individuals with grassroots organizations he suggests that individuals use the resources they have to contribute. Taking the view of an alternative perspective remains an essential asset in positively contributing to society.  According to Kivel, “in order to create contexts where white people and people of color can work together to challenge more fundamental forms of racism, we need to be able to talk to each other about the ways we talk to each other” (p.516). Since the way we communicate our feelings is often cultivated by deep rooted problems, by solely addressing the behavior we fail to recognize the problem of racial discrimination throughout history. A similar misconception about the complexities of identity is discussed by Sengupta. Identities help to form our perspective of how we view the world and Sengupta believes that “all of us are implicated somewhere in our histories or in the histories of our ancestors as victims and as aggressors” (p. 520). As we realize the many realities that co-construct the reality we live in, we can be aware and unite to address the deep rooted problems in the world today.

When reading the articles, I began to think about the multiple realities that become extruded from a single event. The way we construct our perspective relies on our personal experiences. Our identities are complex and I agree with Sengupta that at some point in history our own self or our families have been the victim and have been the aggressor. I think that once we acknowledge this duality we can recognize the similarities that we embody, we have all been the victim and we have all been the aggressor, and we can better understand our own actions as well as the actions of others.

Rather than relying on initial impressions and appearances I have come to realize the importances of recognizing the complexities that reside within individuals and communities. If we can take the time to recognize and try to understand the perspective of someone that embodies different attributes than ourself, we can better understand their actions. As we acknowledge difference we can better communicate and form productive relationships with individuals different from ourself. Rather than accepting our personal perceptions of the events that take place, it remains imperative that we view events through multiple lenses. A complex world filled with complex individuals requires multiple perspectives to provide a comprehensive view. Once we look outside of ourself we can see truths that we never realized existed.



Reading 53, Wimsatt, W. U. In Defense of Rich Kids 
Reading 54, Kivel, P. Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice

Reading 55, Sengupta, S. I/Me/Mine— Intersectional Identities as Negotiated Minefields