Sunday, July 6, 2014

Blog Post 10: Identity

Identities are determined by both biological and physical attributes and often established by those in power. In Reading 4, Garroutte discusses the definition of the native american identity from the perspective of native americans and the US government through blood quantum, “or degree of Indian ancestry” (p. 66). According to Garroutte, “far from being held to a one-drop rule, Indians are generally required—both by law and by popular opinion— to establish rather high blood quanta in order for their claims to racial identity to be accepted as meaningful” (p. 70). Rather than forming one’s own racial identity through personal perspective and choice, it becomes determined by science benefitting those in power. While individuals only need a hint of “black blood” (Garroutte, p. 70) to be considered African American, American Indians are required to contain “high blood quanta” (Garroutte, p. 70) to prove their American Indian identity. The different qualifications for each racial identity exhibits the inconsistencies in the categorization of racial identities. In contrast to the racial identity of African American and American Indian, White remains the normal and homogeneous racial identity that qualifies everyone else as other. In Reading 6, Frankenberg discusses that “whiteness and Americanness both stood as normative and exclusive categories in relation to which other cultures were identified and marginalized” (p. 90). As we recognize the difficulties and harm that result from racial identity qualifications and categorizations we may begin to realize that identity can be determined by personal perspectives rather than scientific analysis.

While reading the two articles I began to think, how can someone else determine my own identity? Do appearances and blood lines determine who we are? How does this categorization of racial identity affect individuals that are adopted into families? In Garroutte’s article, she discusses one example of a child adopted by an Anishnabe man and raised in his culture. Although the child adopted the racial identity of her family, the lack of biological evidence resulted in a lack of recognition by some individuals. According to Gourette, “the U.S. government allows for the assignment of blood quantum only to biological descendants of Indian people, Canada allows for the naturalization of non-Native children through adoption” (p. 68). When racial identity is accepted through adoption in one country and not in another I believe that the construction of racial identity requires attention and discussion. Why do we have to categorize our own identity through biological and physical attributes? Isn’t our identity something more, isn’t our identity our own to determine?

The readings have emphasized the importance of remaining critical of how identities, my own identity and the identities of others, are constructed, who they are constructed by, and why they are constructed. Once we can recognize the elements that comprise identity in our own society, we can look outside of socially constructed identities and look closer at personally constructed identities. If we continue to only acknowledge the biological and physical components of identity we fail to acknowledge true identity, the way individuals see themselves.

Reading 4, Garroutte, E. M., Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America

Reading 6, Frankenberg, R., Whiteness as an “Unmarked” Cultural Category

Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Blog Post 9: Stereotyping

Stereotyping leads to discriminatory actions that promote the division of individuals based on the socially constructed value of specific attributes. According to Pratt, “the process of racial classification would continued to be modified until the first half of the twentieth century with the intent being to make the definition of a white person increasingly more exclusive” (p. 443). Even on today’s society, certain attributes are held in high esteem while others are deemed inferior.  As discussed by Wu, problems of racial generalization lies in that “people can be arranged by racial groups, and, furthermore, that the differences between racial groups are more significant than either the similarities between racial groups or the differences within them” (p. 375). As we categorize individuals by traits that seem to be distinct, we fail to realize the complexities exhibited by each individual. Stereotyping, whether describing a group of individuals in a negative or positive light becomes problematic. Pratt describes the inequitable laws that regarded interracial marriage illegal a little over fifty years ago while Wu discusses the negative affects of the seemingly positive stereotypes, smart, polite, and family oriented, associated with Asian Americans even today. In both cases, generalizing encouraged the elevation of categories, the white race, and suggests the inferiority of others. While stereotyping continues to divide individuals we will fail to recognize the similarities we have as human beings and the differences that make each of us unique.

While reading the articles I began to think about numerous experiences I have had encountering preconceived ideas associated with specific individuals. Often, generalizations lead to a specific treatment and interaction. If someone is known for engaging in positive actions, even if they engage in detrimental actions, the individual is often associated with the positive actions. Similarly, if someone is perceived as engaging in a negative or destructive actions, the individual is associated with negative actions. During student teaching I can remember a conversation I had with one student. The student often made joking remarks in class and enjoyed spending time socializing with friends. One day in his english class, the student was walking near the teacher’s desk and then returned to his seat. The teacher had been circulating within the classroom and when she returned to her desk, her computer no longer worked. The student told me that since he was known as a jokester, the teacher automatically assumed that he caused the computer malfunction. Although the student said that he did not touch the computer, the teacher remained adamant in her initial beliefs. As the student talked to my mentor teacher and me he continued to say that he was not responsible. By automatically assuming the students guilt, because of prior experiences and a preconceived notion that the student was a trouble maker no matter what he said, he will always be a trouble maker in his english teacher’s eyes. In the art room we had seen positive sides to the student and we believed the story he told us.

An awareness of generalizing and reflecting on how we react because of preconceived ideas remains imperative in education and in our daily lives. Simplifications of individuals fail to recognize their innate complexities. Whether stereotyping incorporates positive or negative attributes it remains detrimental to individuals. As we recognize individuals and their actions without preconceived ideas we address and empower individuals rather than the beliefs we associate with them.

Reading 39, Wu, F. The Model Minority: Asian American “Success” as a Race Relations Failure

Reading 44, Pratt, R. A. Crossing the Color Line: A Historical Assessment and Personal Narrative of Loving v. Virginia

Blog Post 8: Perspectives

Within a world where perspectives are formed from personal experiences, alternative realities remain present if we have the ability to look outside of our own perspective to see from the perspective of others. Wimsatt discusses his perspective as a wealthy individual, using his resources to contribute to the world. His article provides a new perspective of wealthy individuals that look outside of their own lives to contribute to grassroots organizations. As Wimsatt discusses his attempt to connect wealthy individuals with grassroots organizations he suggests that individuals use the resources they have to contribute. Taking the view of an alternative perspective remains an essential asset in positively contributing to society.  According to Kivel, “in order to create contexts where white people and people of color can work together to challenge more fundamental forms of racism, we need to be able to talk to each other about the ways we talk to each other” (p.516). Since the way we communicate our feelings is often cultivated by deep rooted problems, by solely addressing the behavior we fail to recognize the problem of racial discrimination throughout history. A similar misconception about the complexities of identity is discussed by Sengupta. Identities help to form our perspective of how we view the world and Sengupta believes that “all of us are implicated somewhere in our histories or in the histories of our ancestors as victims and as aggressors” (p. 520). As we realize the many realities that co-construct the reality we live in, we can be aware and unite to address the deep rooted problems in the world today.

When reading the articles, I began to think about the multiple realities that become extruded from a single event. The way we construct our perspective relies on our personal experiences. Our identities are complex and I agree with Sengupta that at some point in history our own self or our families have been the victim and have been the aggressor. I think that once we acknowledge this duality we can recognize the similarities that we embody, we have all been the victim and we have all been the aggressor, and we can better understand our own actions as well as the actions of others.

Rather than relying on initial impressions and appearances I have come to realize the importances of recognizing the complexities that reside within individuals and communities. If we can take the time to recognize and try to understand the perspective of someone that embodies different attributes than ourself, we can better understand their actions. As we acknowledge difference we can better communicate and form productive relationships with individuals different from ourself. Rather than accepting our personal perceptions of the events that take place, it remains imperative that we view events through multiple lenses. A complex world filled with complex individuals requires multiple perspectives to provide a comprehensive view. Once we look outside of ourself we can see truths that we never realized existed.



Reading 53, Wimsatt, W. U. In Defense of Rich Kids 
Reading 54, Kivel, P. Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice

Reading 55, Sengupta, S. I/Me/Mine— Intersectional Identities as Negotiated Minefields 

Thursday, June 26, 2014

Digital Journal 6/24


Blog Post 7: Change

We often think of ourselves as too small and too insignificant to contribute to major changes in the world. In Reading 49, Collins describes multiple individuals taking action against the discriminatory actions taken against them and in the process contributing to anti-discriminatory impact on the much larger level of society. Even though these small actions seemed insignificant at the time, they have paved the way for anti-discriminatory laws today. Wilson discusses a very similar ripple affect that began with Rosa Parks and continues with individuals with disabilities. The public transportation bus symbolizes a combination of equitable opportunities at work and recreational activities, the ability to stop a public transportation bus that discriminates has empowered individuals to organize social change. Wilson concludes that commemorating Rosa Parks requires the inclusion of equal access to every individual. In Reading 52, Johnson examines the myths associated with the silence that helps to continue the discriminatory beliefs and actions within society. Johnson believes that “it’s not unreasonable to want to make a difference, but if we have to see the final result of what we do, then we can’t be part of change that’s too gradual and long term to allow that” (p. 504). As we find confidence in the notion that each action contributes and we may never know what actions may follow, we can live our lives and pave new paths toward a society that promotes equity and admires diversity.

While reading the articles I began to think about one hot summer day that I spent on the beach. As I sat on a chair in the sun I heard two middle school aged boys talking about the hundreds of jellyfish that had washed up on the shore. They talked about how the jellyfish would sting everyone, so as the jellyfish remained helpless on the beach the boys used their shovels and punctured them with hopes that they would never sting again. Living in Delaware all my life has allowed me to learn about the animals that live close by in the ocean. When I was little I was always taught that moon jellies were harmless creatures that drifted through the water. As I saw the two young boys killing the jellyfish I followed my instinct and quickly ran over to them. I talked with the boys as I picked up a moon jellyfish and showed that that they did not sting, they were just relaxing and sadly they didn’t have the ability to find their way back to the water once they were washed ashore. The boys said that they would now be in charge of putting the jellyfish back into the water where they belonged. As I walked along the beach with the boys placing the jellyfish back in the water, I overheard one of the boys talking to a friend. He said how it was extremely important to get all of the jellyfish back in the water because they did not sting, they were simply floating along. That day turned into a jellyfish rescue day, not just a day of sitting on the beach.

After reading the articles for the class I feel enlightened and debilitated by the tremendous amount of discrimination within our society. I feel more confident after the final readings that subtle actions can have an impact. Although I may not see immediate change, as I take small steps I can believe that change is in progress. I can only focus on my own actions with hopes of paving new paths that positively affect the actions of others. Rather than changing personal beliefs in an oppressive manner, providing new paths allows all individuals to determine a path that parallels their personal beliefs. When I realize that I can focus on my own actions, reactions, and interactions with others change becomes possible.

Reading 49, Collins, G. Lilly’s Big Day
Reading 50, Wilson, C. The Other Movement That Rosa Parks Inspired: By Sitting Down, She Made Room for the Disabled

Reading 52, Johnson, A. G. What Can We Do? Becoming Part of the Solution. 

Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Blog Post 6: Popular Culture

We often construct a personal perspective through the beliefs and ideas presented to us. Popular culture presents ideas that directly affect our own perspective of how we view the world. As discussed by Kendall, “in a mass-mediated culture such as ours, the media do not simply mirror society; rather, they help to shape it and to create cultural perceptions” (p. 449). Popular culture displays unrealistic portrayals of the wealthy, the middle class, the working class, and the poor by idealizing the life of the wealthy, supporting the middle class, and devaluing the working class and the poor. As we accept the beliefs presented by popular culture we fail to recognize alternative perspectives that incorporate the experiences of many. Similarly, the article written by Harris and Carbado describe a color-blind frame from which we view individuals that fails to acknowledge the subtle actions of racism present today. According to Harris and Carbado, “racial frames shape our perception of the facts” (p. 457). The way we interpret images and interactions depends upon how the information is presented. Garland-Thomson discusses the concept of disability cultivated through popular culture making it something to be fixed rather than an individual trait that exhibits variety. As we re-envision the way we think about disability, Garland-Thomson believes that there will be positive changes in the way individuals with disabilities are treated. Our perceptions are affected by the perceptions of others and if we can change the way we look at an individual or a situation it can positively change the interactions we engage in and the perspective from which we view the world.

As I read the three articles I began to think about the images within magazines, newspapers, and advertisements that convey multiple meanings to a viewer. I turn the page of the local newspaper and find an ad for eye glasses depicting a young white woman with a flawless face, perfect long blond hair, and beautiful eyes and next to it an add for a pontoon boat that displays a white couple standing next to one another drinking wine with a small dog sitting alongside. Both articles show a lifestyle, one that supports money and ideas about perfection. At first thought I begin to think how I could see myself in the images and how each could enhance my life, but after some thought and a second glance I begin to think why? Why is it important? Who has decided that this means beauty or the ideal lifestyle? Each image helps to propel a specific meaning and idea. The preconceived notions associated with specific imagery generate ideas that often sway and help to form our own perspective if we let them.

Images are extremely powerful. Visual literacy remains an essential tool in the world today, allowing a viewer to decipher the meaning of images and the intent of the author. Rather than “buying in” on an idea, looking deeper to discover the meaning and the reason behind it is crucial. As I think about the imagery that constantly bombards us today in newspapers, magazines, TV advertisements, and TV shows to name only a few I begin to question whether we automatically assume truth or if we look deeper? I think that when our perspective is dwindled down to emulate those given to us, our choice and individuality is taken away. As we become more aware of the intended messages we can construct our own perspective and decide how popular culture will shape us and our own actions.

Reading 45, Kendall, D., Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America
Reading 46, Harris, C. L. & Carbado, D. W., Loot or Find: Fact or Framed?
Reading 48, Garland-Thomson, R., Disability and Representation

Thursday, June 19, 2014

Blog Post 5: Race

Although race has played a central role in our history, today our society places the concept of race on the back burner with hopes of creating a color-blind society. The action of disregarding race to enhance equal opportunities promotes discrimination through avoidance. Gladwell discusses the role that our unconscious plays with regards to the Implicit Association Test. Within the IAT, participants linked words to images or other words to choose associations, uncovering unconscious beliefs about race. Gladwell states, “the disturbing thing about the test is that it shows that our unconscious attitudes may be utterly incompatible with our stated conscious values” (p. 354). The problem remains in the actions driven by our unconscious and the thoughts that address situations requiring split second thinking. In the article written by Bronson and Merryman, the study uncovered the harm in ignoring explicit discussions about race with young children. A color-blind perspective does not exist and without a guide to race, children make their own assumptions and create their own categories. In an additional article, Wise describes the current beliefs centered around the presidential election of Barack Obama that illuminates the difference between overt racism and the now more widely used subtle racism. Many believe that Obama’s election into office clearly demonstrates an end to racism, but the author believes that it is far from over. Throughout history, achievements of individual black americans have not changed societal beliefs about all black americans, only a selective few which has failed to provide equitable opportunities for all. All three articles describe a racism that hides in the unconscious and the unspoken while discriminatory actions still prevail. 

As I read the three articles I began to think about many situations that I have experienced when adults hush the questions of young children. Rather than acknowledging questions that arise from seemingly awkward situations, a quiet hush quickly quiets and discourages the uncomfortable discussion that could arise. As we teach children to push ideas out of public conversation how can we expect them to rationalize the concept of difference and equity? Questions arise to inform the unknown, otherwise beliefs and thoughts remains understandings based on personal assumptions. Why do we assign awkward or uncomfortable feelings with conversations? How can we change our thinking to embrace questions and uncertainty?

Since no action results in an action, the actions and beliefs of individuals cannot remain neutral. When uncomfortable and unfamiliar situations arise, rather than trying to back away we need to understand that every action is meaningful. Actions that step away from discussions and interactions disregard and ignore. As we reflect on our actions we can become aware of our unconscious feelings, the actions we engage in, and why we engage in such actions. Explicit discussions about race remain imperative to encouraging questions and discussions about the unknown to enlighten previous assumptions. Discussion encourages the inclusion of diverse perspectives and experiences. As we recognize the importance of approaching the unknown with explicit and comprehensive discussion rather than polite conversation we may be able to develop unconscious thinking based on conscious values that utilize multiple perspectives rather than preconceived assumptions. 

Reading 36, Gladwell, M. Blink in Black and White
Reading 37, Bronson, P., & Merryman, A. See Baby Discriminate
Reading 38, Wise, T. Between Barack and a Hard Place